Turpentine Blues: The Strange & Terrible Saga

Slash Pine Slashed For Turpentine
(photo: North Carolina State University)

Turpentine business ain't what it used to be. 


I grew up in the Piney Woods. I still live in the Piney Woods (or the "Pine Belt," as the public relationists and promoters have tagged the underbelly of Mississippi). But the Piney Woods ain't quite as piney as they used to be, unless you happen to think suburban development isn't a sappy mess or wind up in the Pine Grove Treatment Center in Hattiesburg. Among other things, they specialize in sex addiction, so you might want to check in for a few rounds of golf or some heavy metal music. At $37,000 for a month and a half, it's probably no more expensive than renting a condo at Hilton Head and paying greens fees.

But that's not the point here. Or maybe it is. They cut down a bunch of trees to build the city where "Pine Grove" is. The Jefferson Starship built a city on rock and roll, but the city where rock and roll was born was built on yellow pine and turpentine.

Backstory Biology

When Europeans first arrived in North America, longleaf pine (Pinus palustris) forests encompassed millions of acres in the Deep South from Virginia to Texas. Some early explorers described the longleaf forest as "park like" with immense stands of tall, straight trees over a savannah of palmetto, bluestem grasses, and native shrubs. The longleaf pine ecosystem depends on fire, strange as it seems, and controlled burning has routinely used by foresters to manage pine forests for decades. Throughout my life, it has been common to see smoke plumes from back-set fires as the forest service and professional foresters maintain that ecosystem. 

Longleaf pine and its relative, slash pine (Pinus elliotti) are valuable commercial resources, way too valuable for their own good. The ecosystem itself is fragile. 

Many animal species evolved in the "fire ecosystem" of the Piney Wood, The gopher tortoise (Gopherus polyphemus) is the keystone, because over 300 other species cohabitate in their burrows. The black pine snake (Pituophis melanoleucus) and indigo snake (Drymarchon couperi) are noteworthy, as is the red-cockaded woodpecker (Picoides borealis), which doesn't live in gopher burrows but prefers old growth trees for its nest. They're all listed as "threatened" species by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Many other kinds of critters become gopher tortoise roommates: rattlesnakes, notably, but also frogs, invertebrates, and burrowing owls.

READ THIS BOOK!
The beauty of a good stand of longleaf pine may be lost on damyankees who expect purple mountain majesty and crashing surf in their visions of natural beauty, but it's there. Photographers have captured that beauty; Hemard's book, The Pines: Southern Forests is one of them. (Okay, if you're cheap or just passing through, some of the pictures were featured by Smithsonian Magazine a few years ago, so take a look.) 

In a more literary vein, Janisse Ray's Ecology of a Cracker Childhood contains some of the best, nearly-poetic visions I've ever read about the Piney Woods. Her book has been compared with Rachel Carson's Silent Spring, but it's a lot more. So even if you're cheap or just passing through, consider getting a copy. (As I've said before, this blog ain't monetized, so I'm not making a cent off the recommendation.)

Backstory History

Yes, the ecosystem is fragile and beautiful, but unfettered capitalism is strong and greedy, In the 19th Century, it muscled its way through the Piney Woods of the Gulf South. Back in the colonial period, British and Spanish overlords recognized the tall straight trees with their strong, rot-resistant heartwood as ideal ships' timbers. 

The sticky, fragrant pine rosin, was perfect for caulking ships' timbers and preserving rope. "Naval stores" were a major part of the southern economy beginning during the colonial period. That's how the University of North Carolina "Tar Heels" sports teams got their name. Yellow pine lumber and naval stores were an essential component of the Southern economy right alongside cotton, indigo, sugar cane, rice, and Black people. 

When railroads began to penetrate the region after the War of Southern Knuckleheadedness, logging began to expand to vast areas of virgin timber located farther from waterways. Dozens of sawmills sprang up along the main rail lines, The Gulf and Ship Island Railroad was one of the most effective in these parts - if denuding the landscape is the goal - as it splits the difference between the Pearl River and Chickasawhay/Pascagoula basins. 

So the race was on to slash and cut the trees.

1903 Map of the G&SIRR
Nearly every top on the railroad
had at least one sawmill.

Begun in the 1880s by investor W.H. Hardy and completed at the turn of the century under the direction of Joseph T. Jones, the G&SIRR utilized convict labor. It is immortalized in Robert Johnson's song, "Last Fair Deal Gone Down":

My captain's so mean to me,
My captain's so mean to me,
My captain's so mean to me, good Lord,
On that Gulfport Island Road.

Nearly every stop on the G&SIRR was the site of one or more sawmills. Where there were sawmills, there were turpentine stills. The trees kept falling, the saws kept sawing, the sap kept boiling, and the trains kept moving along. 

The main markets for southern yellow pine were overseas,  and the railroads made it easier to move the products from the mills to the docks at Gulfport and Pascagoula. The decline of the northern white pine forests increased domestic demand as well. But all good (or bad) things come to an end.

By the 1920s, the timber boom in the Piney Woods ran out of steam. The big trees were almost all gone. Mill towns like Howison, Ten Mile, Lux, Sanford, and D'Lo dried up and blew away. But in the process, Hardy and Jones had created two cities that would enter the 21st Century as Metropolitan Statistical Areas: Gulfport, the terminus of the "Gulfport Island Road," and Hattiesburg, named after Hardy's wife. Coincidentally, both cities have a "Hardy Street" and U.S. Highway 49 ends (or begins) at Jones Park in Gulfport.

 

"Chip and Dip" - The Turpentine Blues

Although naval stores was considered a by-product of the timber industry - and it certainly was a smaller economic sector than lumber - it was a concurrent activity. The process of collecting rosin is inherently destructive, and trees were cut for timber after they were no longer useful for turpentine. 

Trees were "boxed" during the winter with a triangular collection point chopped into the lower trunk. In the spring, the trees were "chipped" with a pattern of diagonal slashes called a "catface" hacked through the bark above the "box." Then through the late spring and summer, the hardened gum was scraped or "dipped" from these wounds and transported to a turpentine distillery. 

Latter Day Herty System Pot
(circa 1950s)
From the colonial period until around 1900, chip-and-dip gum harvesting remained pretty much unchanged. In 1902, University of Georgia organic chemistry professor Charles Herty patented a clay cup to replace chopped-out boxes. The original Herty pots resembled ordinary clay nursery pots with holes for nailing them in place. Later designs were elongated and often made from galvanized metal.

(As a side note, Charles Herty is remembered in Georgia as much for founding the original Georgia Bulldogs varsity football team as for his work in forest products or for helping found the National Institutes of Health.)

The "Herty system" was significant because it was required less labor and extended the useful life of a tree for a few years by eliminating a deep-cut "box." The Herty system propped up the turpentine industry for a few decades, but it couldn't reverse the effects of unrestricted clear-cutting and little replanting.

As a kid, I remember seeing chipped pines and Herty pots in the woods, but the main source of turpentine by then  was mostly old stumpage left over from the original timber boom. "Stump trucks" were a common sight in my hometown as they hauled ancient tree stumps to Hercules Powder Company, where they were processed into turpentine, rosin, and a variety of other volatile organic compounds. Atmospheric inversions routinely bathed the city in a fartlike miasma that people said smelled "like money."

But let's go back to the Good Old Days®...

Typically, a "crop" consisted of 10,000 trees and yielded about 150 barrels of gum annually. A barrel of crude gum produced six or seven gallons of refined turpentine, and the residue was packed into barrels where it hardened into marketable rosin.

A Scarred Pine "Catface"

You can do the math: 10,000 trees producing  about 150 barrels of gum a year, six or seven gallons of turpentine to the barrel. That's less than 1,000 gallons of turpentine. In 1900, a gallon brought about 40 cents wholesale. So a "crop" yielded $300-400 for a year's worth of labor, barely more than $1000 over the two or three years of life expectancy for that stand of trees. Assuming you could score free trees and unpaid labor, which wasn't that far fetched in the Gulf South 130 years ago, it would only take a million chip-and-dips to pay for 90 days at Pine Grove Treatment Center.

After two or three years, the trees would be ruined, and the turpentine operation would pack up and move elsewhere. The trees were cut for lumber, and the land was theoretically ready for conventional agriculture. (The truth is that Piney Woods dirt pretty much sucks for farming.) Replanting trees didn't become very common until the 1930s. By then, there were very few virgin stands of longleaf pine left in the Southeast.

The entire "season" was about eight months. Both harvesting and distilling were hot, nasty, and dangerous. The workers who boxed and chipped trees were the lowest level in the hierarchy of the Southern forest products industry, housed in remote isolated rural slums called "camps." You get the picture. The workers at turpentine stills were subject to brutal summer heat and frequent explosions. 

Turpentine workers were a wild bunch, uneducated, violent, and poor, and management kept them isolated from the more upscale timber cutters and sawmill workers. Bear in mind that "upscale" in this case is extremely relative; neither logging nor turpentining was particularly lucrative. 

More Fun Than a Barrel of Beauties
Obviously, profitability required access to huge numbers of trees and lots of cheap labor.  As the trees became scarcer, the emphasis shifted to labor, how to get people to do this hot, nasty work and how not to pay them for it. The vast majority of turpentine workers were African-American, some operators leased convict labor, and "camps" used the company store method to force workers into debt slavery.

It's no surprise, then, that turpentine operators - the guys at the top of the pile - were keen to fix prices, exempt their workers from wage-and-hour laws and mandatory benefits including Social Security, and maintain their "peculiar institution" of debt peonage. By the 1930s, they founded the American Turpentine Farmers Association to advance these goals.

The ATFA may have been predatory or benighted or the last gasp of a dinosaur, but who else could have given America the "Miss Gum Spirits of Turpentine" beauty pageant? All hail!











Popular posts from this blog

Shawi, the Trash Panda God

Nerd: Another Strange & Terrible Saga

Bigger Fish to Fry